Monday
Jun102013
Steelcats Logo Evaluations
Monday · Jun 10 · 2013 | 7:00 AM PDTBelow are the eligible logo packages submitted for the Hamilton Steelcats franchise. Evaluate the entries and select a grade for each. When the polls close, ratings will be calculated for each entry to determine which ones move forward to the final voting round next week.
 Chris Smith (current)
|  Matt McElroy
| |
 Craig Wheeler (2008)
|  Nick Marks
| |
 Jesse Feltner
|  Scott Robbins (2008)
| |
 Ross Taylor (2008)
|  Sean Cox
| |
 Bryan Dyck / Chris Smith
|  Johnny Woods
| |
Montreal Olympiques
Reader Comments (7)
Wow....this by far looks like the best set of logos. Going to be impossible to pick a bad one out of here. Nicely done artists!
Agreed, this is far and away the best set of logos. Bravo to everyone who submitted a Steelcats design!
Hamilton. Wow. Easily the best set of logos to choose from, colour me shocked.
I've never been a fan of the current logo so this makes things more interesting!!
As good as they all are, Matt McElroys logo just stands far and above all of them to me, outstanding.
That being said.....
Any of these logos could win and Id be happy!
Bryan Dyck - A great "winter classic" look here, very classy
Johnny Woods - Very slick and simple in a good way!
Craig Wheeler - Fierce logo that just jumps out
Nick Marks - The cartoon feel will probably hurt it when it comes to votes but something about it makes me love it!
Jesse - angle of the whiskers and angle of scratches on secondary - very cool. Johnny - Steel City Cats with a beam and a shield shape - sweet.
Eye of the tiger, I get. Eye of the kitty cat? Not so much. One thing, as a team owner, I would not emphasize about steel is pollution coming out of the stacks.
Every logo here looks pretty good actually. I would not mind any of them winning. Chris or Matt's logos are my favorites though. There isn't enough red in the league as is, and would hate to see it go.
Hamilton's designs are probably the best from top to bottom out of all of the teams we're seeing submissions for. My three favorites have to be Matt McElroy, Bryan Dyck and Nick Marks.
McElroy's design is such a great, modern-looking take on the present logo. It looks super-sharp and is definitely a classic look that is very solid.
Dyck's look is a really nice look that is a lot more traditional and feels like it could definitely belong on a jersey. The color scheme really works with this set, too.
Marks' logo is actually a solid look to me, I like the color scheme and I personally love how the design is a mid-way point between a knight and a cat.
Just realized something. The current design has a stationary cat, so the stacks look like a steel mill. Because it is angled, Matt's cat looks looks more like a steamship or an ocean liner.